Laboré
Poster preview: Effect of a Barrier-Repair Moisturizer Cream on Hydration, Skin Barrier Integrity and Irritation Potency in Sensitive SkinPDF
COSM'ING · 2024

Effect of a Barrier-Repair Moisturizer Cream on Hydration, Skin Barrier Integrity and Irritation Potency in Sensitive Skin

Istiqomah N., Christianti A.M., Jamal S.

COSM'ING Innovation Poster

Sensitive Skin & Barrier

Abstract

A cream combining humectants (glycerin, butylene glycol, saccharide isomerate, hyaluronic acid), emollients (squalane, dicaprylyl carbonate) and an occlusive (shea butter) was evaluated with Corneometer, Tewameter, Mexameter and Visioscan. It delivered long-lasting hydration up to 72 hours, penetrating up to 10 epidermal layers, improved smoothness, and reduced erythema and irritation signs from capsaicin and lactic-acid challenges.

Key findings

  • Long-lasting hydration up to 72 hours and up to 10 layers depth of the epidermis
  • Skin smoothness improved with an 18.31% reduction in the SEsm index, from 72.69 to 59.39 over 14 days
  • Skin hydration rose 26.19% by Corneometer, from 47.27 at baseline to 59.65 at day 14
  • No increase in erythema index on capsaicin-induced skin 10 minutes after application
  • 95% of subjects agreed skin sensitivity was reduced 15 minutes after application, and 90% after 10 minutes

Methods at a glance

Design
Multi-centre, double-blind study consisting of four trials
72-hour moisturizing study
35 female subjects, once-daily use for 14 days; Corneofix F 20, Corneometer CM 825 and Tewameter TM 300, with deep hydration measured at Day 17
Long-term efficacy study
20 female subjects, twice-daily use for 14 days; Corneometer CM 825 and Visioscan VC 98
Instrument-based irritation study
30 female subjects, single application; irritation induced with capsaicin, erythema index by Mexameter MX 18 before and at 3 and 10 minutes
Self-perception irritation study
20 female subjects, single application; irritation induced with 10% lactic acid, questions immediately and at 5, 10 and 15 minutes
Base
Oil-in-water cream mixed with a Multimix homogenizer; white opaque cream at pH 4.5 to 5.5

Data from the poster

Values reproduced as printed in the source document.

Table 1. Long-term efficacy after 14 days of twice-daily use (n = 20).
ParameterInstrumentBaselineDay 14Change
Skin hydrationCorneometer CM 82547.2759.65+26.19%
Skin smoothness (SEsm)Visioscan VC 9872.6959.39-18.31%
Table 2. Self-perceived reduction in sensitivity after 10% lactic acid induction (n = 20).
Time after applicationSubjects agreeing sensitivity was reduced
Immediately75%
5 minutes75%
10 minutes90%
15 minutes95%

Background

Stinging, burning, itching and redness are common symptoms of sensitive skin. One of the causes is weakening of skin barrier function due to poor skin moisture. Many people declare their skin is sensitive and find it difficult to identify suitable products. A cream formulation containing a combination of humectants (glycerin, butylene glycol, saccharide isomerate and hyaluronic acid), emollients (squalane and dicaprylyl carbonate) and an occlusive (shea butter) was therefore prepared as a strategy for restoring the skin barrier and moisture to normal condition.

Objective

To evaluate the effect of the moisturizer cream on moisturizing properties, skin barrier integrity and irritation potency using instruments and self-assessment questionnaires.

Materials and methods

The combination of moisturizing agents was added into an oil-in-water cream base and mixed with a Multimix homogenizer, resulting in a white opaque cream with a pH around 4.5 to 5.5. Efficacy testing was a multi-centre, double-blind study consisting of four trials. A 72-hour moisturizing study used a once-daily use test in 35 female subjects to evaluate moisture retention and water barrier function with Corneofix F 20, Corneometer CM 825 and Tewameter TM 300 after 14 days of application, with moisturizing and deep hydration properties measured at Day 17, three days after the last application. A long-term efficacy study used a twice-daily use test in 20 female subjects to evaluate moisturizing and smoothness benefits with Corneometer CM 825 and Visioscan VC 98 after 14 days. An instrument-based irritation study applied the product once in 30 female subjects, with irritation induced by capsaicin and the erythema index measured with Mexameter MX 18 before, 3 minutes and 10 minutes after application. A self-perception irritation study applied the product once in 20 female subjects, with irritation induced by 10% lactic acid and questions asked immediately and at 5, 10 and 15 minutes after application.

Results and discussion

The cream formulation showed significant improvement in skin moisturizing and skin barrier, with long-lasting hydration up to 72 hours and up to 10 layers depth of the epidermis. It also helped improve smoothness as shown in the SEsm index. Post tape stripping at 0, 3, 6 and 10 strips, a significant reduction was noted in water loss and improvement in skin hydration at Day 15, after two weeks of regular product use, and at Day 17, 72 hours after last use of the test product, compared with baseline. Improvement of skin smoothness was shown by an 18.31% reduction in the SEsm index, from 72.69 at baseline to 59.39 at Day 14, and skin hydration improved by 26.19% as measured by Corneometer, from 47.27 at baseline to 59.65 at Day 14. There was no increase in erythema index on skin induced by capsaicin 10 minutes after application of the moisturizer cream. On self-perception of skin sensitivity signs such as stinging, burning and itching caused by lactic acid induction, 75% agreed sensitivity was reduced right after application, 75% after 5 minutes, 90% after 10 minutes and 95% after 15 minutes.

Conclusion

Symptoms of sensitive skin can be reduced by improving skin barrier strength, which can be achieved with moisturizer therapy. The combination of humectant, occlusive agent and emollient was shown to increase skin hydration, improve skin smoothness and give long-lasting moisture. Combining all three is the best choice, because a humectant alone can cause excessive water loss from the dermis through evaporation into a lower-humidity environment, so it needs to be combined with an occlusive agent. Adding an emollient further improves the texture and appearance of the skin by filling the gaps between corneocytes, improving lubricity and restoring epidermal lipids. The study showed that a product with a triple-action moisturizer can increase skin moisture and improve skin barrier integrity, and subjects with improved skin moisture exhibited a reduction in skin sensitivity from lactic acid and capsaicin induction.

Back to all studies